Showing posts with label rail. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rail. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Costs of rail projects increase

Further to yesterday's news regarding the additional funds needed for the Northrail, Business Mirror reports today that other rail-based projects have also jacked up their costs. Normally, the opposition would see this as an additional burden to the people which clearly smacks of corruption. The government and the proponents of the project would naturally deny anything irregular with the need for additional funds, but to dismiss the possibility of corruption altogether would be far from realistic.

Nevertheless, the plans look beautiful on paper, and these projects should be railroaded, not necessarily at all costs though, if that means money is no object.

$280M more sought for Phase 1 of Northrail due to design change

The North Luzon Railways Corp. (NLRC) is requesting for an additional $280 million for the Northrail Phase 1 project due to a change in its project design.

The proposal was recently submitted to the National Economic and Development Authority’s (Neda) Infrastructure Committee (InfraCom), the interagency committee in charge of advising President Arroyo on infrastructure development, including railways, highways and airports.

Neda said the revision in its project design involved changing the narrow-gauge tracks, which were initially approved by the Neda Investment Coordination Committee (ICC) to sturdier standard or double-gauge tracks.

Neda Deputy Director General Rolando Tungpalan said the NLRC cost-increase proposal will have to go through an evaluation of the InfraCom and then go through the ICC process starting with the ICC Technical Board until the proposal obtains Neda Board approval.

However, Tungpalan said, in line with the plans of the government to speed up all infrastructure projects and programs, the Neda will also hasten its evaluation and approval of the NLRC’s request for additional funding.

The additional cost will be added to the initially approved cost of $503 million.

The China Export Import Bank will finance $421 million of the total project cost, while the remaining $82 million will be shouldered by the national government.

Phase 1 Section I of the Northrail project runs from Caloocan to Malolos, Bulacan. The contractor for the project is the China National Machinery and Equipment Group.

The NLRC stated on its web site (www.northrail.com.ph) that it aims to end 2008 with a project accomplishment rate of 61.87 percent, mostly comprised of civil works.

It also aims to acquire additional right-of-way (ROW) and relocate affected utilities by December 2008. The NLRC expects to complete the civil works for the project by August 2009.

Earlier, the Neda said seven infrastructure projects have posted cost overruns of more than P2.27 billion in the first half of 2008.

These projects include the Metro Iligan Regional Infrastructure Development Project, Rural Road Network Development Project III, Central Mindanao Road Project, Urgent Bridge Construction Project for Rural Development, and Iloilo Flood Control II.

Further, the Philippine National Railways (PNR) and Light Rail Transit Authority (LRTA) submitted cost overrun reports that showed that the Northrail-Southrail Linkage Project Phase I or the commuter- train part of the entire Northrail project will post a cost overrun of P648.12 million and the LRT Line I Capacity Expansion Project Phase II will post a P1.622-billion-worth cost increase.

The reasons include increase in prices of labor, materials and equipment/price adjustment/price escalation, changes in scope or variation orders/supplemental agreements, high bids, value-added tax and other taxes, foreign-exchange movement, increase in consulting-service costs, administrative costs, and increase in ROW or land acquisition and resettlement costs as well as price adjustments.

The 32-kilometer Northrail-Southrail linkage Phase 1 will run from Caloocan to Alabang and service 16 stations along the route. The PNR estimated that the average travel time from end-to-end is 30 to 35 minutes, while 21 new diesel railcars are expected to accommodate 187,000 passengers daily.

Phase 1 will cost $50.42 million, and around 70 percent, or $35 million, will be funded through a concessional loan from the Economic Development Cooperation Fund of Korea.

The balance will be in the form of export credit from the Korean Export-Import Bank.

The LRTA said, on the other hand, that the LRT Line I capacity expansion project Phase II will aim to extend its services to an additional 40,000 passengers per hour per direction (pphpd) from the already expanded capacity (Phase I) of 27,000 pphpd.

The agency said the project is intended to cope with the present and expected increase in volume of passengers using LRT Line 1 and the additional passenger demand to be generated under an integrated MRT Line 1, 2 and 3 system.

The project costs P11 billion, and is 85-percent financed by the Japan Bank of International Cooperation.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Northrail project needs more funds - GMANews.tv

MANILA, Philippines - Citing change in project design, the North Luzon Railways Corp. has requested to increase the fund allocation for the Northrail Phase 1 project, which will run from Caloocan City to Malolos, Bulacan.

The NLRC has proposed to the Infrastructure Committee of the National Economic and Development Authority for an additional $280 million for the China-funded project from the original budget of $503 million.

The Infracom is in charge of advising the President on infrastructure development including railways, highways, and airports.

NEDA officials said the revision in Northrail's project design involved changing the narrow-gauge tracks which were initially approved by the NEDA Investment Coordination Committee (ICC) to sturdier standard or double-gauge tracks.

Rolando Tungpalan, NEDA deputy director general, said the cost increase proposal will undergo review by the Infracom and then go through ICC process starting with the ICC Technical Board until it gets approval from the NEDA Board, which is chaired by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.

However, Tungpalan said that in line with the plans of the government to fasttrack all infrastructure projects and programs, the NEDA will also fasttrack its evaluation and approval of the NLRC's request for additional funding.

Of the original total amount of the project, the China Export Import Bank will finance $421 million of the total project cost while the remaining $82 million will be shouldered by the national government.

The contractor for the project is the China National Machinery and Equipment Group

The NLRC said that it aims to end 2008 with a project accomplishment rate of 61.87 percent, mostly comprised of Civil Works.

It is also seeking to get additional Right-of-Way (ROW) and relocate affected utilities by next month. The NLRC is targeting to complete the civil works for the project by August 2009.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

MRT riders face dilemma

While the DOTC, the MRT Corp. and the city government of Mandaluyong lock horns on the issue involving the unpaid realty taxes involving MRT-3's stations in Ortigas, Shaw Boulevard and Boni Avenue, the daily commuter, who already suffers from insufferably long queues and packed trains that sometimes fail, may soon have to bear an even bigger burden.

Business Mirror reported yesterday that MRTC general manager Roberto Lastimoso threatened to cut the MRT-3's trips from North EDSA only to Santolan, and from Taft up until Guadalupe, should Mandaluyong City make good on its bid to wrest ownership of the aforesaid stations, following the writ of possession awarded to the city government by the Regional Trial Court of Mandaluyong City.

The arguments by each of the parties may be summarized as follows:
  • MRTC - under our contract with the Republic of the Philippines, represented by the DOTC, we were only going to build the overhead railway and the stations, and the DOTC would operate it and pay us monthly rent.
  • DOTC - we're a government agency exempt from paying realty taxes.
  • Mandaluyong City Government - we're not taxing the DOTC; we're taxing the MRTC, and all those small firms which own commercial establishments and have put up billboards in the stations within our jurisdiction.

The issues are not new. In previous years, similar mass-based transport facilities have been levied realty taxes by city governments. ParaƱaque City once sought to hold a public auction to sell the portions of the NAIA in its territory. Of course then Mayor Joey Marquez was shut up by the Supreme Court. Pedestrian Pinoy thinks that the city government of Mandaluyong should take a huge step back and rethink its strategy with regard to taxing the MRT-3 and taking over 3 of its stations. The concessions given to the MRTC were designed to be particularly attractive because the government could not itself undertake to build the railway, despite having the mandate to do so. And the concessions are legal (though they may not necessarily be advantageous, such as the sovereign guarantee). If private corporations involved in the construction and operation of public infrastructure were to be put at the mercy of city "kingdoms" who think themselves outside of the collective efforts at improving the economy, then the people -- who would be left expecting too much from a national government that has little will, and even less resources, to undertake big-ticket projects -- would only have their huge expectations dashed.

Saturday, October 25, 2008

MRT-3 to borrow trains from the LRTA

The Business Mirror reported yesterday that the DOTC intends to borrow 40 trains from the LRTA to fill up the shortage of the MRT-3. This option is being explored because according to DOTC Secretary Leandro Mendoza, the cost of new coaches is prohibitive, and that delivery of newly-purchased trains would take time. 

Now Pedestrian Pinoy is not sufficiently informed of the precise dimensions of the trains of either the LRT-1 or that of the MRT-3, and despite the similarities -- they both run on rails and are powered by overhead cables -- based on experience, the design and size of these carriages are not even remotely alike. Take a look at these photos of the interior of the trains:


Secretary Mendoza admits this when he said that the LRT-1 coaches need to be converted to fit the MRT-3 tracks. "The LRT cars are slightly different from the MRT-3 coaches." Perhaps Secretary Mendoza's knowledge of the our elevated railways isn't so different from that of Pedestrian Pinoy's.

Nevertheless, this proposal begs further questions: will the MRT-3 borrow LRT-1's new coaches? Or the vintage, pre-1990s trains? Also, does the LRT-1 enjoy such a huge surplus of trains that it is actually in a position to lend its cars to the MRT-3? 

Barely a decade into full operation, the MRT-3 has breached its riding capacity. It is the usual story of many of our mass-based transport facilities: the absolute lack of foresight and incredible if not ill-advised cutbacks (whether as a result of extraordinary inflation or illegal kickbacks) have affected design and possibilities for future growth and redevelopment. The options that are now being explored to address the manifold of problems besetting the MRT Corp. are, at the very least, disconcerting. In the end, it is the riding public that suffers as a result of the government's incompetence and the private sector's failures.